Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette lists guaiac wood, cashmeran, clove, a chestnut accord, red berries and vanilla. Guaiac is the fire, clove and chestnut the roasting, and vanilla makes it cosy rather than sooty. Candles and diffusers share the name.
What Wearers Say
One wearer enjoys its sweet, nutty campfire character.
Another likes how the smoky opening becomes smoother and more vanillic without losing its woodsmoke impression.
Some wearers find the woodsmoke too literal to enjoy wearing.
One wearer finds it too sweet and floral, with more vanilla than the campfire they wanted.
Great for
Try it if woodsmoke, roasted chestnut and vanilla appeal.
Not for
Sample first if lingering campfire smells or sweet vanilla put you off.
Fragrance Notes
Best Seasons
Best For
How It Compares
vs. Dossier Woody Chestnut
Dossier's Woody Chestnut is its By the Fireplace interpretation: chestnut, guaiac, clove and vanilla with smoky cade. Margiela lists chestnut, guaiac, clove, red berries, cashmeran and vanilla.
Read the full comparison →